Equality is a relationship between man and
man. It’s one of mankind's ultimate ideal. In an equal society, there is no
division of classes, wealth or power. This was the predominant goal of the Russian
Revolution as well as the animal revolution in the story Animal Farms. The
thought of having an equal society is admirable, though it’s only a fantasy.
In the story Animal Farms, 7 commandments
were established soon after the fleeing of Mr. Jones, with the 7th- all animals
are equal, being the most important. Later on, bit by bit, the 7 commandments
were soon deformed, and the equality which the commandments promised and protected
perished.
Why doesn’t animalism work? Why did the
equality the seven commandments promised vanish? The key is the natural
division between intellectual and physical labor. It’s true that after the expulsion
of Mr. Jones, the animals worked together happily as though equality was
established. The “honey moon” of a revolution would never last long. There
wasn’t anyone in charge of the animals, so a power vacuum was naturally
created. It was only a matter of time the next group of animals assumes
totalitarian control. It’s not that the animals in charge would necessarily
have more rights; in fact, an eminent leader would drive a society forward, for
his commands would be for the people’s sake. It’s the corruption of the leader
that obliterates the society. A leader who is selfish, and craves for more
power and privilege would do anything to fulfill his wants. Usually, he who
craves power would take advantage of the naivety of the labor force, contorting
the commandments rather indistinctly until it becomes what he desired. By then,
there would be no more equality and he would, of course, become the next
oppressor. It is only a matter of time an ambitious and malevolent leader comes
to power. An equal society is very fragile and modifiable; it’s not at all a
perpetual one.
The other more perspicuous reason is that the
animals were born to be different. All men are created to be somewhat equal; it
is only men themselves who place themselves above equality. On the contrary,
there’re various kinds of animals in a barn yard with distinct differences.
There are, for instance, simple animals such as horses and cows, are naturally manipulated
by the so-called “Brain Workers”. Larger animals such as horses and cows would
be the only ones feasible to carry a heavy load-you can’t expect a cat or dog
to do such heavy labor. Characteristic of the animals plays a huge role in
inequality as well: selfish animals may attempt to work less than the more
diligent ones; pompous and pretentious animals would think that they deserve
more, therefore taking more rations. There are lots of chasms to animalism that
prevents it from becoming a reality, but in summary, the main flaw that causes
the idea of an equal society to be escapism and crumple is the fact that it
neglects the animal nature. As Frank Zappa once said,” Communism doesn't work
because people like to own stuff.” For an equal society to work, people have to
be robotic, programmed to work without complaints or ambition.
The animals will never be equal, nor will our
world. Fortunate was we are, we mustn’t forget the inequality and the
discriminations that still exist globally. By contributing some of our
surpluses to the world, it won’t cure the imparity, but it will certainly help.
No comments:
Post a Comment